She tells stories that never happened. Is she lying?

My mum confidently tells me things that never happened — that her sister visited her yesterday (she passed away years ago), that she worked somewhere she never did. Should I correct her?

Your mum isn't lying. Lying requires knowing the truth and hiding it — what her brain does is different: when memory has a gap, it automatically fills it with fragments of other memories, and the resulting story feels as real to her as any other. This is called confabulation and it's involuntary.

To correct or not to correct?

As a rule of thumb: correct as little as possible. Correction ('Auntie passed away eight years ago, Mum!') rarely fixes the truth and often causes distress — the person might grieve as if it were the first time. Instead, ask yourself: is this story harming anyone? If not, let her live in it.

How to respond in the moment

Engage with the emotion without validating the facts: if she tells you about her sister's visit with joy, respond to the joy — 'That's lovely, what did you talk about?'. Use the cue to bring up real memories: 'Tell me what Auntie was like when she was young'. If the story distresses her, gently redirect to another activity or topic.

Only pay attention to confabulations with consequences: accusations against others, stories that make her want to leave home, or financial decisions based on false facts. In these cases, manage the situation (more vigilance, inform those involved) without turning every episode into a battle for the truth. And record the progression to share with her doctor.

Sources that informed this content